A Lifetime of punishment does not deter Molesters, treatment can
Franz Kafka's novel "In the Penal Colony" describes a machine that terrible punishment and excruciating pain prisoner strapped to a wooden bed causes. Above the prisoners parallel fixed bed repeatedly with large needles pumps on the prisoners body, piercing and tattooing. This device is only for the purpose to physically punish and shame the prisoners for their crimes, not to rehabilitate them. It can be analogizednew chemical castration to California law and the proposed single handcuff law for a second offense child molesters.
An updated version of Kafka's novel is written by the Women's Coalition. This group, which advocates tougher laws against sex offenders, played a large role in convincing the legislature to order the chemical castration law, AB3339, effective 1st January passed. Now people will be twice convicted of child abuse with injections of Depo-Provera, a hormone imposedDisabled sex drive and fertility. The injections are first given one weeks before a person released from prison. There is no obvious purpose of the new law except to continue to persons who already have their sentences had to be punished for their crimes.
The problems with chemical castration, the frightening prospect that it can be administered to the wrong individual, and doubts about the effectiveness of the drug. Dr. Fred F. Berlin, director of the BaltimoreNational Institute of Sexual Trauma, disputes the idea that Depo-Provera injections will work just "pro forma" and indicates that "it's like a diet drug ... You have to want to have to stop eating." See Mike Lewis, "The New castration," California Lawyer, January 1997, p. 21
But Dr. Berlin is going too far. Diet drugs suppress the appetite. If the drug by the desire to lose weight is supported, there is a reasonable likelihood that weight loss occurs. There is noAnalogy of child molesters and Depo-Provera, which has an inhibitory effect on both libido and fertility.
Child molesters have no problems with their libido, they have problems with behavioral control, psychological fragility and drug abuse. Often from homes where sexual abuse was common come. Such assistance is Depo-Provera on child molesters used by using penicillin for rapists: The drug has no bearing on the problem and is therefore invalid.
In addition,Depo-Provera has serious side effects in addition to loss of sexual desire and fertility: breast enlargement, hot flashes and hair loss. The drug "victims" are subjected to painful physical changes and, more importantly, they suffer the loss of the normal and healthy sexual relationships and the ability to have a family. Until a child molester solves nagging problems of internal control is to harass drive, regardless of whether they are chemically castrated.
MostPsychiatrists believe that chemical castration should only be chosen voluntarily by the child molester and must be accompanied by psychological counseling. In other words, the castration is not the answer to the problem, the mental element is the factor that must be addressed. The Women's Coalition has announced that it is currently working on "phase two" of the chemical castration law - the single handcuff law. This scheme would be twice convicted child abusers forced to wear handcuffs to a singlefor life after their release from prison. The theory that the public would like to inform that a child molester among them is. "Brand of metal" therefore, the public "safe" from such people, the public will be embarrassed by is
The proposed single handcuff law is problematic from the start. A child can not see the child molester or the handcuffs before the attack. Molesters could easily hide the fact under a jacket sleeve or glove so that the cuff would handcuff unnoticed by potential victims. Moreimportant to treat not the handcuffs is not the problem and as such, it will not prevent future crimes. The Women's Coalition tunnel vision and their desire to protect society precludes it from seeing the monstrous impact of the proposed condemnation of shame there.
Shame conviction is not the solution to child molesters. Child molesters are not good. They have momentum insists that tell them they need to control something smaller and more vulnerable than themselves. Their need for control drives themoutside the law, and notices. Many of them know their behavior is illegal, but still not to keep the perspective of social norms. Shame conviction will not change child molester "behavior. To address this problem, we should mandate that the treatment of the real problems that they pursue, so that society be protected really looking address. Eliminate With branding these people for life; We will encourage them to seek help and change.
The appropriate penalty is neither the one nor phasePhase two of the Women's Coalition modern horror novel. The legislature has already determined the appropriate punishment for crimes. The Board of prison terms to determine which prisoners are to the point where they can re-enter society and lead a normal life on probation reinstated. The Women's Coalition usurped the latter and tells us that now is punishment continued to be delivered after the corresponding set.
The blind trust to handle other pubic condemnationSolutions that are used, while the abuser is still imprisoned and still are safe to the public. An inmate was committed, binding and severe psychological counseling are invited. The victim, could often from the same family as the child molester, and other family members invited to attend these meetings in an open forum atmosphere, to increase awareness of the problems in order to promote the recognition of warning signs and trigger, a venting of emotions , fears andConcerns. Prisoners could be subject to lie detector tests superficial, to decide on their dismissal if they bothered even more vulnerable to others.
Despite such practical solutions by the Women's Coalition punishment of the form is not as monstrous torture machine, but the medical and public displays visible. Although there is a marked difference in shape, the resemblance is maintained: the punishment is imposed only intended to shame: it is not to treatthe symptoms of crime.
Shame conviction only guaranteed to provide hope, help and self-awareness never occur. It's a Band-Aid to cover up the frustration and fear that the company feels when the questions are resolved on the hand very hard. Shame conviction is a crutch used by the company if they want protection, but his hands are tied feels. But society is not protected .... be in the penal colony.
By Sharon B. Morris
Thanks To : plasma screen tvs pet medical insurance
No comments:
Post a Comment